Solar Week - Ask a Question



Come here during Solar Week (next one: March 22-26, 2021) to interact. To post a question, click on your area of interest from the topics below, and then click on the "Ask New Question" button. Or EMAIL or tweet or plant in Answer Garden your question about the Sun or life as a scientist to us -- and watch for it to appear here.  You can also visit our FAQs (frequently asked questions). In between Solar Weeks in October and March, you can view all the archives here.

PrevPrev Go to previous topic
NextNext Go to next topic
Last Post 4/13/2010 8:55 AM by  KD Leka
sun
 2 Replies
Sort:
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Author Messages

Anonymous





Posts:


--
4/13/2010 7:25 AM

    hannah h

    In theory could a comet impact large enough do any damage to the sun we on earth would notice?


    Terry Kucera



    Basic Member


    Posts:328
    Basic Member


    --
    4/13/2010 8:09 AM

    Hi Hannah,

    We have not seen any signs of comets hitting the surface of the Sun - they just seem to burn up in the atmosphere.

    Unlike the case with Jupter which was hit by Comet Shoemaker-Levyin 1994: then we could see where the comet hit the cloud tops: http://www2.jpl.nasa.gov/sl9/image111.html

    The Sun is a lot bigger and hotter then Jupiter, though. I think any object big enough to show damage on the Sun would not by classified as a comet. People will keep looking to see if they can actually see where those comets burn up, though!

    Terry


    KD Leka



    Basic Member


    Posts:115
    Basic Member


    --
    4/13/2010 8:55 AM

    greetings,

    I concur with what Terry wrote, a comet is simply too piddly to really make an impact on the solar surface. Specifically, comets are not very dense, and break up easily when faced with a very hot atmosphere such as the Sun's.

    On the other hand, what might be very interesting would be an impact of a large asteroid on the sun. With a much denser rock like or even solid iron core, there is the possibility that a large solid body could survive passing through the outer parts of the solar atmosphere. Still, for us to observe it, it would have to be massive. Remember that when you see an image of a sunspot on the sun, if it's a medium sized sunspot or larger, it's easily as big as the entire Earth!. I'm not sure we would be able to detect an asteroid or metallic body that was much smaller as it was seen against the solar disk. But it is fun to think about.

    You are not authorized to post a reply.


    Twitter Feed

    Scientist Leaderboard

    Name # of replies
    Multiverse skin is based on Greytness by Adammer